I'm always fascinated by new technology and particularly ways social media works in our world.
So it was natural for me to sign up for Groupon.com, the internet based deal program that works with local vendors to offer special coupons and discounts for products or services.
Sometimes these deals are just incredible - from 50% off food products to half price golf to yoga for $19 per month rather than $140.
But what about using coupons for health care services?
Sounds odd, I know, but this has been a common practice for years with aesthetic services and cosmetic procedures or treatments.
It's not uncommon at all to see deals for "free Botox" or discounts on micro-dermabrasion or chemical peels.
But would you be influenced by a coupon for "free prostate exam" or "buy one get one free mammogram"? Or would you just think that provider was weird?
It may sounds strange, but actually this happens every day.
It's hidden behind the cloak and dagger world of the pharmaceutical sample closet.
For years the drug sample has been the easiest tease to entice patients to try a different medication. Sometimes they are very helpful -- a difficult medication to use (like an unusual dispenser for a spray on product), unusual side effects ("try it before you buy it"), or most commonly the patient has no money and they leave with a bag full of free drugs.
But these are certainly short term solutions and may or may not lead to a patient actually buying the product.
It's no surprise that most of the samples in the closet are for chronic medications -- not for something you have to take for a week or less.
But the interesting invasion into the sample closet has been the coupon.
Now not quite "groupon-like," coupons are now available for almost all name brand, non-generic medications -- particularly if they are early in their evolution of release.
This is how it usually works: you decide you want to prescribe a new anti-hypertensive (an expensive way to say blood pressure medication). Compared to a generic medicine which might fall under the $4 per month Walmart plan, this medication might be $300 per month.
But, there might be some advantages: lower incidence of side effects, easier dosing regimen, or maybe its more effective. There usually is a real medical reason despite what some Washington pundits might say.
Newer drugs usually work better.
But, nevertheless it costs $300. That's roughly half of some people's Social Security check.
Now with insurance this medication would be a lot cheaper (for the patient) but it is very likely that it would not fall under the "preferred plan" of their prescription drug coverage.
That means that it would likely cause a higher co-pay such as $50 as opposed to $5.
This is where the pharmaceutical coupons come into play. Now, instead of advertisement laden boxes of pills, the sample closet is full of boxes full of coupons or discount cards.
Patients are asked to call a 1-800 number to activate the card, "register" (which means the company collects information on the patient, disease, and provider), and then the card can be used to off set part of the extra cost related to use of the expensive medication.
These cards usually function as "discount cards." That is, they will provide either a certain reduction in your copay amount, or they will fix the total cost of medication at a certain point.
Most of the cards require you have insurance to use them. There is no free lunch here, and the drug companies themselves don't want to be out the total cost of the drug, only part of their margin.
Sometimes there are limits on the amount of benefit you can receive. The card may only be good for three refills, or it may be unlimited. You want to make sure you check this carefully before you continue to refill your medication.
Pharmacies as rule don't like to deal with these cards. Much like grocery stores don't like to deal with coupons.
There is an extra step for them, possibly some activation required on their part and certainly they have to carry additional float, in addition to your insurance, before they will get paid.
What's fascinating to me is that these provide a direct incentive to use a more expensive medication.
Now, as I've outlined here, there are some benefits of these cards. But let's face it, these are expensive medications -- there is no free lunch.
It's the incentive that seems bizarre. Physicians and hospitals are forbidden from discounting co-pays, not collecting deductibles, or for offering covered services for less than the contracted amount in most insurance contracts.
There have been several lawsuits already between rival health care systems in communities where one hospital might write off co-pays or deductibles to entice patients to choose their facility over the competitor.
This might be like a patient knowing that regardless if he has Blue Cross Blue Shield insurance, for example, they could choose either emergency room -- because the cost would be the same to them.
Patients with high deductible insurance plans are particularly susceptible to this type of gaming. The catch is that the hospital is able to collect enough money on the subsequent procedure or test to offset the loss of the deductible.
The problem is for the insurance company and the other insured patients that are on the policy.
It removes the incentive to stay within network and comply with the contract that makes indemnity insurance work in the first place.
Everyone has to play by the same rules.
So why do pharmaceutical companies get to use these discount cards?
I'm not sure I can answer that question, but I hope I've been able to shed some light on these type of cards and discounts.
In some situations they may be very helpful. If you require an expensive medication, particularly one that is new, be sure to ask your physician if the company offers any type of discount card.
If not, then asked them for a lower priced, generic alternative.
Otherwise, just be aware that these cards can get you established on an expensive medicine for you only to find out that the benefits were temporary.
Also be careful if the company is going to send you a rebate. This puts the risk on you for collecting the money.
So although not quite Groupon.com type coupons, there are some discounts available for expensive medications.
You just may have to shop around and be an educated consumer-patient.
Monday, March 7, 2011
Study finds unnecessary breast biopsies: maybe needles should stick to being lost in haystacks
By Linda Timmerman, Ed.D.
I get frustrated when I hear about research studies that say women don’t need mammograms every year or before a certain age, not all lymph node dissections are necessary, and now many breast biopsies are done just to line the pockets of physicians and hospitals.
A recent article in the American Journal of Surgery suggested that physicians are doing too many biopsies and should favor doing fine needle aspirations or biopsies (the "FNA").
The FNA is a procedure where a needle is inserted into the tumor either based on palpation of the lump or by the use of a sonogram to guide it to the proper location.
Then using suction, some of the cells are removed and examined under the microscope.
So who do you listen to?
I get frustrated when I hear about research studies that say women don’t need mammograms every year or before a certain age, not all lymph node dissections are necessary, and now many breast biopsies are done just to line the pockets of physicians and hospitals.
A recent article in the American Journal of Surgery suggested that physicians are doing too many biopsies and should favor doing fine needle aspirations or biopsies (the "FNA").
The FNA is a procedure where a needle is inserted into the tumor either based on palpation of the lump or by the use of a sonogram to guide it to the proper location.
Then using suction, some of the cells are removed and examined under the microscope.
I thought about my friend, Robbie, when I read the findings of the research study.
Robbie found a lump under her arm. She was still young, so the doc thought it was probably just a cyst or infected lymph node. They did a fine needle aspiration (FNA). Results: all clear.
We celebrated with margaritas and Mexican food at Don Jose’s!
Three months later, the “lump” was growing – another FNA – good results – more margaritas!
Six months passed and Robbie went for her well woman checkup. Her OB/Gyn just didn’t like the feel of the lump – so a third FNA followed by the celebratory margaritas!
Fast forward a few weeks. Robbie dropped by to say she was going back to the surgeon. “I know it’s nothing, “ she said, “but it just bothers me knowing it’s there. I’m asking him to take it out.”
“Lump” removed – positive for cancer – invasive ductal carcinoma with lymph node involvement. A modified mastectomy, 8 rounds of chemo, and 35 radiation treatments followed – and Robbie’s been cancer free for 15 years.
Now to be fair, biopsies in general are samples.
Think of a loaf of bread.
You decide you want to serve it for Thanksgiving but you're not sure its fresh. So you pull out several slices and examine them. All ok. No green stuff here.
You put it on the table and then one guest pulls out a different piece, and guess what? A Pasteur prize addition to your holiday meal.
But FNA's are even more of a sample: small fragments of cells pulled through a hypodermic needle. Analysis requires special training and certainly has a margin of error that is bigger than examining a larger piece of tissue.
Now to be fair, biopsies in general are samples.
Think of a loaf of bread.
You decide you want to serve it for Thanksgiving but you're not sure its fresh. So you pull out several slices and examine them. All ok. No green stuff here.
You put it on the table and then one guest pulls out a different piece, and guess what? A Pasteur prize addition to your holiday meal.
But FNA's are even more of a sample: small fragments of cells pulled through a hypodermic needle. Analysis requires special training and certainly has a margin of error that is bigger than examining a larger piece of tissue.
Robbie is alive today because she listened to her body and followed her “gut feeling” that the lump needed to come out.
So what’s the takeaway message?
If you find a lump, go to a center that specializes in breast cancer.
Find a surgeon and radiologist you can trust.
And most of all follow your gut feelings.
Listen to your body.
Maybe you’ll be one of the fortunate ones whose breast biopsy was unnecessary.
Find a surgeon and radiologist you can trust.
And most of all follow your gut feelings.
Listen to your body.
Maybe you’ll be one of the fortunate ones whose breast biopsy was unnecessary.
Linda Timmerman, Ed. D. is a two-time cancer survivor and life long educator. She blogs regularly about cancer survival and real information from real people with the disease.
Sunday, March 6, 2011
What Are the Odds? Why information discovery about cancer on the internet might be like online gambling
By Linda Timmerman, Ed.D.
You might think the first place you visit after being told you have cancer would be to a cancer doctor, or oncologist.
But you'd be wrong.
The first stop for most of us? The internet.
Google any form of cancer, and a plethora of websites are instantly available. Some are good, and some are downright dangerous (but that's for another blog).
We tell ourselves we're looking for information about the disease, where to seek treatment, what types of treatments are available.
But what we really want to know is "what's the prognosis?"
"Can I survive this cancer?"
"What are my chances?"
"How long do I have?"
I remember the evening a friend and colleague called and said, "Can you come over? The doctor says I have esophageal cancer, and my wife and I just need to talk."
Truthfully, I didn't even know there was such a thing as esophageal cancer -- so before grabbing my car keys and husband, I starting Googling.
Unfortunately, my friend and his wife were doing the same thing.
By the time we arrived at their home, they were completely focused on the statistics: the 5-year survival rate ranges from 70% to 5% depending on the stage of the cancer at diagnosis.
His first words were, "this thing is going to kill me."
I certainly advocate knowing everything you can about your disease. Some cancers have low survival rates primarily because by the time symptoms appear the cancer is too entrenched or has spread.
It's the nature of the beast.
But how one copes with and acts on this information is vital, I believe, for every survivor traveling the road to the new normal.
Greg Anderson, diagnosed with stage IV lung cancer and given 30 days to live in 1984, went on to found the Cancer Recovery Foundation. He interviewed over 16,000 cancer survivors who had been told they were "terminal" and shares their wisdom in his book, Cancer: 50 Essential Things To Do.
It's a "must read" for survivors. Cancer, say Anderson, must be dealt with on all levels: physical, psychological, and spiritual.
When I was diagnosed with breast cancer in 1997, my first act was to look to the sky and ask, "Oh God, what am I supposed to learn from this?"
On hearing the diagnosis of bladder cancer just last year, my first thoughts were, "Obviously, I'm a slow learner."
To live with cancer, we must know and believe that we can have a quality life and achieve wellness. If the five-year survival rate is 2%, then focus your energy on being in that 2% group.
Emile Coue, a nineteenth century pharmacist in France, encouraged his patients to practice positive affirmation rather than focusing on the fears associated with a serious illness.
His words still ring true: "Every day, in every way, I am getting better and better."
Linda Timmerman, Ed. D. is a two-time cancer survivor and life long educator. She blogs regularly about cancer survival and real information from real people with the disease.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
You might think the first place you visit after being told you have cancer would be to a cancer doctor, or oncologist.
But you'd be wrong.
The first stop for most of us? The internet.
Google any form of cancer, and a plethora of websites are instantly available. Some are good, and some are downright dangerous (but that's for another blog).
We tell ourselves we're looking for information about the disease, where to seek treatment, what types of treatments are available.
But what we really want to know is "what's the prognosis?"
"Can I survive this cancer?"
"What are my chances?"
"How long do I have?"
I remember the evening a friend and colleague called and said, "Can you come over? The doctor says I have esophageal cancer, and my wife and I just need to talk."
Truthfully, I didn't even know there was such a thing as esophageal cancer -- so before grabbing my car keys and husband, I starting Googling.
Unfortunately, my friend and his wife were doing the same thing.
By the time we arrived at their home, they were completely focused on the statistics: the 5-year survival rate ranges from 70% to 5% depending on the stage of the cancer at diagnosis.
His first words were, "this thing is going to kill me."
I certainly advocate knowing everything you can about your disease. Some cancers have low survival rates primarily because by the time symptoms appear the cancer is too entrenched or has spread.
It's the nature of the beast.
But how one copes with and acts on this information is vital, I believe, for every survivor traveling the road to the new normal.
Greg Anderson, diagnosed with stage IV lung cancer and given 30 days to live in 1984, went on to found the Cancer Recovery Foundation. He interviewed over 16,000 cancer survivors who had been told they were "terminal" and shares their wisdom in his book, Cancer: 50 Essential Things To Do.
It's a "must read" for survivors. Cancer, say Anderson, must be dealt with on all levels: physical, psychological, and spiritual.
When I was diagnosed with breast cancer in 1997, my first act was to look to the sky and ask, "Oh God, what am I supposed to learn from this?"
On hearing the diagnosis of bladder cancer just last year, my first thoughts were, "Obviously, I'm a slow learner."
To live with cancer, we must know and believe that we can have a quality life and achieve wellness. If the five-year survival rate is 2%, then focus your energy on being in that 2% group.
Emile Coue, a nineteenth century pharmacist in France, encouraged his patients to practice positive affirmation rather than focusing on the fears associated with a serious illness.
His words still ring true: "Every day, in every way, I am getting better and better."
Linda Timmerman, Ed. D. is a two-time cancer survivor and life long educator. She blogs regularly about cancer survival and real information from real people with the disease.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
Location:Stonewall Dr,Streetman,United States
Labels:
bladder cancer,
breast cancer,
cancer,
esophogeal cancer,
essential,
gambling,
Google,
googling,
Gred Anderson,
internet,
lung cancer,
odds,
oncologist,
online,
prognosis,
terminal
Saturday, March 5, 2011
Teen Wrinkles: Is Botox Appropriate for Teen Agers?
A recent article on abc.com concerning Botox use in teen age girls was somewhat alarming, but not surprising.
As with everything related to teenagers, there is continued pressure to do more, and to do it earlier.
You can fill in the blank here -- from drinking to drugs to sex to alcohol -- for eons teens have been creating a demand for those vices mostly left for adults.
But is Botox a vice?
Let's put aside medical necessity for a moment and focus on just the idea of catering to your teen's wants and desires.
If little Jane wanted something..."really really bad"...would she automatically get it?
Now before anyone here immediately jumps to the conclusion that "none of my girls are getting Botox" let me assure you that it's not that simple.
You only have to hang around my office for a day and see tattoos in 16 year olds, piercings in tongues, noses, and yes, labia's in 15 year olds, and very UVB florescent light bulb induced tanned 14 year olds.
Yes, just so you know, parents have a tendency to say yes.
My suspicion is young teen age girls can be a very convincing lot. I have one, a young teen age girl that is, and she can create a very good argument on most issues.
Fortunately for now I'm good at holding strong to my opinions too. The fruit doesn't fall far from the tree.
So you see it's not really a stretch to put Botox in the same category as these other body manipulations or treatments.
As for medical necessity, well that's another matter.
Botox, or botulinum toxin, for those that have missed the craze that has become the most popular cosmetic procedure in America, is a poison that is injected into facial muscles to induce temporary paralysis or weakening.
Sounds bizarre and dangerous, but it's really not. It's so simple and relatively risk free that most people can have it done over the lunch hour and no one will ever know.
It's painless, most of the time "bruise less", and the results are gradual over a few days to a week.
You just start to get that "rested look" as the week goes on.
The primary use for Botox is for glabellar (between your eyes), forehead, and crow's feet wrinkles. And it works exceptionally well here.
Cost is minimal compared to many other cosmetic procedures, but its effects are temporary in that you will require another treatment in 3 to 4 months.
How much?
It varies, but a good guess is about a $100 per month per area. That is, for your forehead and crow's feet it might be about $400 every 3 or 4 months depending on how much medication is required to achieve the result you want.
The use of Botox though has expanded to other "off label" uses including softening of smoker's lines, correction of gummy smile, and treatment of bunny lines.
So for teenagers you might wonder where is the clinical necessity? I mean, as a group they don't suffer from glabellar rhytides or smoker's lines. Right?
But there is another direction that Botox has taken over the last several years, and that is in the realm of "wrinkle prevention."
Now this may sound bizarre, but it actually makes some sense.
Here's how Botox used to work: a woman would adamantly state that "I'm never having Botox." At about age 35 there would be some accidental encounter with either an old high school boy friend or a 10x makeup mirror and a dermatology emergency would be created.
"I can't have this!"
"Why do I have this!"
A nice dermatologist in a black t-shirt would show compassion and understanding, "You're 35 dear. It always happens at 35."
This would not be taken well by the patient. Just for the record.
So Botox would now become a necessity and not a luxury or something that she "would never do." It happens every day, read: every day, in our office.
But the story doesn't stop here. I wish it could be so easy.
For most women, Botox is a miracle drug. The wrinkles just fade away over a few days and now the old boy friends and makeup mirrors are much easier to face.
But for some, the results are not as dramatic. As permanent vertical lines or wrinkles are imprinted on your skin, they may be softened but not erased by the cosmetic injection.
They just don't disappear.
This can be an alarming reality for many women who feel that modern medicine can fix anything. And for many cosmetic problems, we can. But it may be more complicated than a five minute Botox injection.
So this brings up the whole idea of "wrinkle prevention."
If you intervene early, weaken the muscles that are creating the permanent lines and wrinkles, can you obviate these cosmetic concerns as a person grows older?
This is the million dollar question -- and yes, it is a million dollar question because that is what is spent (hundreds of millions really) on this approach every day.
Women are coming in earlier and earlier even before wrinkles form to treat areas that are potential areas of cosmetic concern.
So this is the driving force for most teens.
It's just a natural course that these procedures have moved from those in their thirties, to the twenties, and now to the teens.
But is it appropriate?
Well for me, I don't think so. Could you make some sort of credible medical argument? Maybe.
Can you convince me? Probably not.
My view of the world is that teenagers need to grow a few wrinkles.
Wrinkles show age and wisdom. That might help you know you really shouldn't get your tongue pierced.
As with everything related to teenagers, there is continued pressure to do more, and to do it earlier.
You can fill in the blank here -- from drinking to drugs to sex to alcohol -- for eons teens have been creating a demand for those vices mostly left for adults.
But is Botox a vice?
Let's put aside medical necessity for a moment and focus on just the idea of catering to your teen's wants and desires.
If little Jane wanted something..."really really bad"...would she automatically get it?
Now before anyone here immediately jumps to the conclusion that "none of my girls are getting Botox" let me assure you that it's not that simple.
You only have to hang around my office for a day and see tattoos in 16 year olds, piercings in tongues, noses, and yes, labia's in 15 year olds, and very UVB florescent light bulb induced tanned 14 year olds.
Yes, just so you know, parents have a tendency to say yes.
My suspicion is young teen age girls can be a very convincing lot. I have one, a young teen age girl that is, and she can create a very good argument on most issues.
Fortunately for now I'm good at holding strong to my opinions too. The fruit doesn't fall far from the tree.
So you see it's not really a stretch to put Botox in the same category as these other body manipulations or treatments.
As for medical necessity, well that's another matter.
Botox, or botulinum toxin, for those that have missed the craze that has become the most popular cosmetic procedure in America, is a poison that is injected into facial muscles to induce temporary paralysis or weakening.
Sounds bizarre and dangerous, but it's really not. It's so simple and relatively risk free that most people can have it done over the lunch hour and no one will ever know.
It's painless, most of the time "bruise less", and the results are gradual over a few days to a week.
You just start to get that "rested look" as the week goes on.
The primary use for Botox is for glabellar (between your eyes), forehead, and crow's feet wrinkles. And it works exceptionally well here.
Cost is minimal compared to many other cosmetic procedures, but its effects are temporary in that you will require another treatment in 3 to 4 months.
How much?
It varies, but a good guess is about a $100 per month per area. That is, for your forehead and crow's feet it might be about $400 every 3 or 4 months depending on how much medication is required to achieve the result you want.
The use of Botox though has expanded to other "off label" uses including softening of smoker's lines, correction of gummy smile, and treatment of bunny lines.
So for teenagers you might wonder where is the clinical necessity? I mean, as a group they don't suffer from glabellar rhytides or smoker's lines. Right?
But there is another direction that Botox has taken over the last several years, and that is in the realm of "wrinkle prevention."
Now this may sound bizarre, but it actually makes some sense.
Here's how Botox used to work: a woman would adamantly state that "I'm never having Botox." At about age 35 there would be some accidental encounter with either an old high school boy friend or a 10x makeup mirror and a dermatology emergency would be created.
"I can't have this!"
"Why do I have this!"
A nice dermatologist in a black t-shirt would show compassion and understanding, "You're 35 dear. It always happens at 35."
This would not be taken well by the patient. Just for the record.
So Botox would now become a necessity and not a luxury or something that she "would never do." It happens every day, read: every day, in our office.
But the story doesn't stop here. I wish it could be so easy.
For most women, Botox is a miracle drug. The wrinkles just fade away over a few days and now the old boy friends and makeup mirrors are much easier to face.
But for some, the results are not as dramatic. As permanent vertical lines or wrinkles are imprinted on your skin, they may be softened but not erased by the cosmetic injection.
They just don't disappear.
This can be an alarming reality for many women who feel that modern medicine can fix anything. And for many cosmetic problems, we can. But it may be more complicated than a five minute Botox injection.
So this brings up the whole idea of "wrinkle prevention."
If you intervene early, weaken the muscles that are creating the permanent lines and wrinkles, can you obviate these cosmetic concerns as a person grows older?
This is the million dollar question -- and yes, it is a million dollar question because that is what is spent (hundreds of millions really) on this approach every day.
Women are coming in earlier and earlier even before wrinkles form to treat areas that are potential areas of cosmetic concern.
So this is the driving force for most teens.
It's just a natural course that these procedures have moved from those in their thirties, to the twenties, and now to the teens.
But is it appropriate?
Well for me, I don't think so. Could you make some sort of credible medical argument? Maybe.
Can you convince me? Probably not.
My view of the world is that teenagers need to grow a few wrinkles.
Wrinkles show age and wisdom. That might help you know you really shouldn't get your tongue pierced.
Thursday, March 3, 2011
Gas Prices and Health Insurance
My good friend Tom Stewart posted the price he paid for gasoline this morning on FaceBook.
As a funny retort I mentioned he could use his savings on health insurance premiums to pay for the extra cost of gas.
He didn't think it was funny.
With the Obamacare bill that was passed last year and all the debate on health insurance for "all Americans," it will not come as a surprise for most that we will see little reduction in what we spend on health care.
First of all, the bill purportedly covers a host of new people (estimates are vague at best, but let's say 30 million) which aren't already covered.
There is a very real cost associated with these new participants in the health care scheme. No doubt they were accessing our health care system in some form or fashion prior to the new bill, but with the extra benefits afforded patients under the new plan, there will be additional costs.
States are now grappling with the fact that much of the cost of this health care bill is being passed on them, and of course on to the citizen tax payers.
We have seen the state response vary from attempting to obtain a waiver so they don't have to participate, to filing federal lawsuits (now on the way to the Supreme Court), to threatening Wisconsin-Democrat style political participation -- we'll just leave.
What's really interesting to me is the reason for the bill in the first place: "we can't afford these rising health care costs."
Mr. Obama used his town hall stump speech around American espousing how much health care costs add to the cost of a Chevrolet, how Medicare is going broke and won't be able to care for the baby boomers, and how cheap medications are if you buy them in Mexico or Canada.
So in the satirical wit that I'm known for, I thought I would try to draw some comparisons and contrast with the cost of Zocor and Shell Premium Gas:
1) Has anyone ever looked at the cost of energy used to produce a Chevrolet? From the coal used to make the energy to make the steel to the oil used to power the locomotives to carry the parts to a Detroit plant operated on electricity produced from natural gas and coal. Get the picture?
2) Theoretically Zocor will make you live longer and healthier. Has the rising cost of gas at the pump lead to being able to live longer and healthier with the energy we have?
Doubtful.
Instead most energy companies use the added profits to search for more traditional energy sources rather than create ways to make do better with what we have.
You only have to drive through the northern part of central Texas and see the moon-scape remains of Chesapeake energy as they search for natural gas. With the advent of horizontal drilling technologies and "fracturing" they have created sources of "clean and affordable" natural gas.
3) The new health bill will limit the purchase of cheaper medications from foreign companies. Does any of our current energy policy limit the purchase of foreign oil?
4) We import most of our energy, and we export most of our drug technology to the rest of the world. If we limit the profits of pharmaceutical companies will we stifle drug innovation and new therapies or treatments? If we limit our reliance on foreign oil, will we then promote better reliance on living with what we have and promoting a more sustainable energy policy?
5) PHARMA is a new set of rules that prevent the pharmaceutical companies from entertaining physicians and consumers of health care services. Do we have similar rules relating to energy companies? I wonder if Halliburton has a Washington, DC office?
6) There might be a similarity in the two issues relating to radiation. The bill puts significant curbs on physician owned facilities -- mostly radiology services like MRI and CT machines. And despite the reliability and environmentally friendly nuclear power option -- we aren't building any significant plans anytime soon.
7) And do we provide energy for "all Americans?" I mean, we are talking about energy...isn't the availability of energy a basic right, like health care? You would be hard pressed to survive in today's world without using energy in some form or fashion. Are we providing a policy that helps my elderly parents with the cost of their electric or propane bill? What about young single moms who can't get to work because of the cost of gasoline? Are we providing energy vouchers to help them?
8) And what about the cost of health care and energy compared to GDP? This "gross domestic product" argument was one of the strong reasons that lead to passage of the greatest transfer of wealth in American history in the Obamacare bill.
The story was told that health care was making up "too much of GDP."
So, I ask, how much is too much? Have we applied the same argument to energy costs? Just saying.
Conclusion: the health care bill will add costs to most Americans in an economy that is increasingly dependent on foreign energy sources.
So every time you fill up that tank, don't think about how much you are saving on health insurance premiums.
Switch to mid-grade from premium.
That's what most patients will find their choice to be in their new health care insurance.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
As a funny retort I mentioned he could use his savings on health insurance premiums to pay for the extra cost of gas.
He didn't think it was funny.
With the Obamacare bill that was passed last year and all the debate on health insurance for "all Americans," it will not come as a surprise for most that we will see little reduction in what we spend on health care.
First of all, the bill purportedly covers a host of new people (estimates are vague at best, but let's say 30 million) which aren't already covered.
There is a very real cost associated with these new participants in the health care scheme. No doubt they were accessing our health care system in some form or fashion prior to the new bill, but with the extra benefits afforded patients under the new plan, there will be additional costs.
States are now grappling with the fact that much of the cost of this health care bill is being passed on them, and of course on to the citizen tax payers.
We have seen the state response vary from attempting to obtain a waiver so they don't have to participate, to filing federal lawsuits (now on the way to the Supreme Court), to threatening Wisconsin-Democrat style political participation -- we'll just leave.
What's really interesting to me is the reason for the bill in the first place: "we can't afford these rising health care costs."
Mr. Obama used his town hall stump speech around American espousing how much health care costs add to the cost of a Chevrolet, how Medicare is going broke and won't be able to care for the baby boomers, and how cheap medications are if you buy them in Mexico or Canada.
So in the satirical wit that I'm known for, I thought I would try to draw some comparisons and contrast with the cost of Zocor and Shell Premium Gas:
1) Has anyone ever looked at the cost of energy used to produce a Chevrolet? From the coal used to make the energy to make the steel to the oil used to power the locomotives to carry the parts to a Detroit plant operated on electricity produced from natural gas and coal. Get the picture?
2) Theoretically Zocor will make you live longer and healthier. Has the rising cost of gas at the pump lead to being able to live longer and healthier with the energy we have?
Doubtful.
Instead most energy companies use the added profits to search for more traditional energy sources rather than create ways to make do better with what we have.
You only have to drive through the northern part of central Texas and see the moon-scape remains of Chesapeake energy as they search for natural gas. With the advent of horizontal drilling technologies and "fracturing" they have created sources of "clean and affordable" natural gas.
3) The new health bill will limit the purchase of cheaper medications from foreign companies. Does any of our current energy policy limit the purchase of foreign oil?
4) We import most of our energy, and we export most of our drug technology to the rest of the world. If we limit the profits of pharmaceutical companies will we stifle drug innovation and new therapies or treatments? If we limit our reliance on foreign oil, will we then promote better reliance on living with what we have and promoting a more sustainable energy policy?
5) PHARMA is a new set of rules that prevent the pharmaceutical companies from entertaining physicians and consumers of health care services. Do we have similar rules relating to energy companies? I wonder if Halliburton has a Washington, DC office?
6) There might be a similarity in the two issues relating to radiation. The bill puts significant curbs on physician owned facilities -- mostly radiology services like MRI and CT machines. And despite the reliability and environmentally friendly nuclear power option -- we aren't building any significant plans anytime soon.
7) And do we provide energy for "all Americans?" I mean, we are talking about energy...isn't the availability of energy a basic right, like health care? You would be hard pressed to survive in today's world without using energy in some form or fashion. Are we providing a policy that helps my elderly parents with the cost of their electric or propane bill? What about young single moms who can't get to work because of the cost of gasoline? Are we providing energy vouchers to help them?
8) And what about the cost of health care and energy compared to GDP? This "gross domestic product" argument was one of the strong reasons that lead to passage of the greatest transfer of wealth in American history in the Obamacare bill.
The story was told that health care was making up "too much of GDP."
So, I ask, how much is too much? Have we applied the same argument to energy costs? Just saying.
Conclusion: the health care bill will add costs to most Americans in an economy that is increasingly dependent on foreign energy sources.
So every time you fill up that tank, don't think about how much you are saving on health insurance premiums.
Switch to mid-grade from premium.
That's what most patients will find their choice to be in their new health care insurance.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
Location:Oil Country, West Texas
Wednesday, March 2, 2011
Does brown fat look better than white fat?
I learned early on in the practice of dermatology that patients like to look tan. It just seems to be a part of human DNA.
It just feels good for most people to be out in the Sun.
There is all the hubbub about melatonin, endorphins, and the like that are released when you spend the day sitting by the pool. But, personally, I think most folks simply think they look better tan.
I've spend the better part of my professional career with a sideline passion of stamping out the tanning bed industry.
They have been a likable lot to spar with: they're always tan, smile a lot (I think they also bleach their teeth -- I'll save that for another blog), and generally espouse junk science about the benefits of being naked inside of an adult sized EZ Bake oven.
And probably I would have had a hard time convincing the state legislature that they needed to be regulated if ten-year-olds hadn't been also subjected to tanning beds.
Yes, it's true. (I'll save parenting for another blog too.)
Tanning is addictive.
There are multiple studies about the addictive nature of recreational tanning. But do you really need a study to convince you that 20 minutes alone every day in a warm cocoon away from your phone (you can insert boss, teachers, children, whatever here) and listening to your iPod must feel good?
Men my age do the same thing with ESPN. It's called zoning out.
Now the difference is that men end up with love handles and an extra 20 pounds somewhere. Tanners end up looking cool.
And when you are fat and tan you look better than if you're fat and a stark white guy. At least that's what my patients tell me.
So is there a connection now with the epidemic we have of adult obesity and tanning? That's the question I pose.
Tanning certainly crosses cultural and BMI lines. There are thousands of self proclaimed health nuts who spend an hour at gym, cycle a hundred miles, or who run marathons and are as dark as a mahogany chest of drawers.
I've talked with these patients many times but I just can't break the nut of making them stop tanning. They just feel too good until they get a melanoma.
I had a patient recently ask me, "Just what am I supposed to do? I have to be outside."
The answer is you can be outside, but be smart about it.
Wear sunscreen of at least an SPF 30 (ignore those recommendations of SPF 15 or more; they were written by people near Canada), avoid mid-day sun and exercise or work outdoors in the morning or late afternoon, and wear a hat.
No one expects you to be a bat and live in a cave. You have to live your life and enjoy it.
But what about those people who don't exercise, eat a regular diet of McDonald's, and are well, not skinny?
Do they feel they look better if they are tan?
I think they do.
Of course the activities that get you tan are not bad: vacationing in Cancun, sitting by the pool, fishing with your buddies, or even recreational tanning.
But people look at their skin, fat or skinny, and perceive that it looks better if it's bronze. We have created a culture that tan equals health.
This of course is now regardless of body mass index.
But its not. That is, neither being fat or tan is healthy.
Both lead to their own independent set of problems.
So what can you do about it?
Well, for the fat part, we all know what to do (execution may be difficult): eat less and exercise more.
But for the tan part we have been stymied in the past because the only way to get tan was the primordial sitting on a beach towel in the sun, or paying $30 a month for a membership at Planet Tan.
There was always the "self tanner."
But for many of us this was the Vitalis-like concoction QT, a brown liquid that left your knees, hands, and elbows looking like a navel orange.
This scared a generation of Americans away from chemical, inorganic, and preservative containing self tanning products. And into the hands of a dermatologist treating skin cancer.
But that's not true anymore. Now there are a host of self tanners and spray on tanning devices that offer tans indistinguishable from those obtained the old fashioned way.
Neutrogena makes a very nice product that sprays a micro spray of self tanner that works very well. Its "no rub" nature makes it easy to apply in the morning before work and its slow onset of action just makes you start to look tan over a few days.
The machine of choice right now seems to be a device called Mystic Tan. Briefly, you stand upright, hold out your arms, listen to some Star War's type beeping, and it sprays you like a car wash. With a little rub down when your done and you have instant tan.
And finally there is the newest phenomenon: air brush tanning.
Long only available to either the rich and famous or those on Dancing with the Stars, airbrush tanning has now entered the mainstream marketplace.
Most places are charging between $25 to $35 and a technician sprays on the non-toxic, harmless tanning spray while you either wear paper undergarments or go commando.
It usually doesn't require any wiping down, dries instantly, and looks very natural.
Read: very natural. I'm the so called expert and I can't tell unless I look close.
And its a whole lot safer than baking in the sun or sitting in a tanning bed, regardless of your weight.
So, the best advice is to lose weight, eat a healthy diet, and stay out of the sun. But if you want to be tan, do self tanning.
Why? Because self-tanned fat looks better than tan real fat.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
It just feels good for most people to be out in the Sun.
There is all the hubbub about melatonin, endorphins, and the like that are released when you spend the day sitting by the pool. But, personally, I think most folks simply think they look better tan.
I've spend the better part of my professional career with a sideline passion of stamping out the tanning bed industry.
They have been a likable lot to spar with: they're always tan, smile a lot (I think they also bleach their teeth -- I'll save that for another blog), and generally espouse junk science about the benefits of being naked inside of an adult sized EZ Bake oven.
And probably I would have had a hard time convincing the state legislature that they needed to be regulated if ten-year-olds hadn't been also subjected to tanning beds.
Yes, it's true. (I'll save parenting for another blog too.)
Tanning is addictive.
There are multiple studies about the addictive nature of recreational tanning. But do you really need a study to convince you that 20 minutes alone every day in a warm cocoon away from your phone (you can insert boss, teachers, children, whatever here) and listening to your iPod must feel good?
Men my age do the same thing with ESPN. It's called zoning out.
Now the difference is that men end up with love handles and an extra 20 pounds somewhere. Tanners end up looking cool.
And when you are fat and tan you look better than if you're fat and a stark white guy. At least that's what my patients tell me.
So is there a connection now with the epidemic we have of adult obesity and tanning? That's the question I pose.
Tanning certainly crosses cultural and BMI lines. There are thousands of self proclaimed health nuts who spend an hour at gym, cycle a hundred miles, or who run marathons and are as dark as a mahogany chest of drawers.
I've talked with these patients many times but I just can't break the nut of making them stop tanning. They just feel too good until they get a melanoma.
I had a patient recently ask me, "Just what am I supposed to do? I have to be outside."
The answer is you can be outside, but be smart about it.
Wear sunscreen of at least an SPF 30 (ignore those recommendations of SPF 15 or more; they were written by people near Canada), avoid mid-day sun and exercise or work outdoors in the morning or late afternoon, and wear a hat.
No one expects you to be a bat and live in a cave. You have to live your life and enjoy it.
But what about those people who don't exercise, eat a regular diet of McDonald's, and are well, not skinny?
Do they feel they look better if they are tan?
I think they do.
Of course the activities that get you tan are not bad: vacationing in Cancun, sitting by the pool, fishing with your buddies, or even recreational tanning.
But people look at their skin, fat or skinny, and perceive that it looks better if it's bronze. We have created a culture that tan equals health.
This of course is now regardless of body mass index.
But its not. That is, neither being fat or tan is healthy.
Both lead to their own independent set of problems.
So what can you do about it?
Well, for the fat part, we all know what to do (execution may be difficult): eat less and exercise more.
But for the tan part we have been stymied in the past because the only way to get tan was the primordial sitting on a beach towel in the sun, or paying $30 a month for a membership at Planet Tan.
There was always the "self tanner."
But for many of us this was the Vitalis-like concoction QT, a brown liquid that left your knees, hands, and elbows looking like a navel orange.
This scared a generation of Americans away from chemical, inorganic, and preservative containing self tanning products. And into the hands of a dermatologist treating skin cancer.
But that's not true anymore. Now there are a host of self tanners and spray on tanning devices that offer tans indistinguishable from those obtained the old fashioned way.
Neutrogena makes a very nice product that sprays a micro spray of self tanner that works very well. Its "no rub" nature makes it easy to apply in the morning before work and its slow onset of action just makes you start to look tan over a few days.
The machine of choice right now seems to be a device called Mystic Tan. Briefly, you stand upright, hold out your arms, listen to some Star War's type beeping, and it sprays you like a car wash. With a little rub down when your done and you have instant tan.
And finally there is the newest phenomenon: air brush tanning.
Long only available to either the rich and famous or those on Dancing with the Stars, airbrush tanning has now entered the mainstream marketplace.
Most places are charging between $25 to $35 and a technician sprays on the non-toxic, harmless tanning spray while you either wear paper undergarments or go commando.
It usually doesn't require any wiping down, dries instantly, and looks very natural.
Read: very natural. I'm the so called expert and I can't tell unless I look close.
And its a whole lot safer than baking in the sun or sitting in a tanning bed, regardless of your weight.
So, the best advice is to lose weight, eat a healthy diet, and stay out of the sun. But if you want to be tan, do self tanning.
Why? Because self-tanned fat looks better than tan real fat.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
Location:San Angelo, Texas
Labels:
airbrush,
BMI,
fat,
laws regulating tanning,
legislature,
Mystic Tan,
Neutrogena,
QT,
self tanner,
skin cancer,
tanning,
tanning bed
Tuesday, March 1, 2011
Cancer Survivors New Normal: Dr. Linda Timmerman explores living through cancer -- twice!
(Please join me in welcoming Dr. Linda Timmerman to docdano.com. Linda is a two-time cancer survivor and patient champion with a long history in education and health care. She will host a new video series blogging about cancer survival and the new normal that occurs after a cancer diagnosis. The focus will be on real stories from real people that survive, treat, or live with someone with cancer.)
By Linda Timmerman, Ed. D.
About a year ago, it became official: I’m a “double D”!
A Dual Diagnosis Cancer Survivor.
It was devastating in 1997 to hear the words from my breast surgeon, “what we have here is invasive ductal carcinoma.” There are no words to describe how I felt thirteen years later when I heard my urologist say, “it’s a really large tumor and I’m 99% certain it’s malignant.”
During chemo and radiation for the breast cancer, all I wanted was a “normal” day. I thought that would come at the end of treatment.
Silly me.
Cancer changes everything about life, physically and emotionally. It took me several years to realize that “normal” simply didn’t exist. So I started seeking my new normal – that place where I could feel comfortable, safe, and confident again.
And I almost found it.
I no longer panicked when I made the annual appointment for my mammogram, chest x-rays, and blood tests. I went days, weeks, and even a few months without thinking about cancer. I changed careers, loved learning new things and meeting new people, my husband and I built a home on the lake and we bought a condo in the city.
Our children got married and had children. Life was good.
And then the day I’ve now named “Red Thursday” occurred. Three surgeries, two rounds of chemo, and umpteen million tests later, I’m seeking that “new normal” again. I still have two years of chemo treatments every six months and scopes of my bladder every three months, but I’m surviving.
During treatment, it’s physically difficult. And there are days when I feel I’m hanging by a thread emotionally. For right now, at least, that’s my “new normal.” It’s very much like driving in the car with my GPS navigation system.
Every now and then, I take a wrong turn – or I simply choose to go another way – and the voice sighs, “recalculating.”
That’s what happens in the new normal – we all recalculate and then press on. Any like any journey where you’re not certain if you’re on the right path, there are both tears and joys in the unknown.
There are thousands on the road to new normal with me.
My goal for this blog is to encourage cancer survivors to tell their stories, to become educated about their disease, and to draw strength and courage from each other.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)