Moles are like stars.
And patients are like constellations.
And the number of these lesions is like the number of stars in the universe.
There is no way to see every mole, document every mole, or even have every mole examined by a dermatologist.
So patients play an important role in skin cancer diagnosis and recognition. Teaching and educating patients on discovering these lesions is essential.
We have to make melanoma astronomers out of our patients.
So here's what I say:
1) "The most sensitive sign for a melanoma is a mole that is changing in size and color -- not specific, but sensitive. So call me if you see a mole you are concerned about that is changing in size or color."
2) "Look for 'ugly ducklings.' That is, don't focus on your moles as individual lesions -- rather look at them as a group. Look for moles that are ugly ducklings and don't look like their neighbors. If you see one of these ugly ducklings, then bring it to my attention."
3) For non-melanoma skin cancer: "You don't need to see me every time you get a pimple. But if you get a non-healing wound or sore that lasts longer than six weeks, then we probably need to take a look."
The three steps are simple, but they represent good advice in finding skin cancer, particularly melanoma, early.
Saturday, March 19, 2011
Friday, March 18, 2011
Your health records: more like a blog, or more like Twitter?
For over a decade I traveled 30 miles south to a rural clinic along I-45 in Fairfield, Texas. There I met one of those physicians that people always think of when they think the word "doctor."
Dr. John Keller is a community icon.
Born south of this small town, he practiced medicine there for over 50 years. Now he's retired, and the community is at a loss.
Though certainly not the cause, his retirement coincided with the roll out of a new electronic medical record, or EMR (sometimes AKA EHR).
This reminded me of a story from Dr. Keller that he related to me over a decade ago. He told me that when he first went into practice records were kept on 3"x 5" note cards.
As someone who has served in various administrative capacities over the years, I've always remembered Dr. Keller's initial non-electronic medical record. And I suspected that his care was super, despite the limitations of space on that card.
Today, EMRs are becoming more and more common. There is still significant resistance from some physicians because of the lack of a unified national standard of connectivity.
That is, one system still can't talk to another.
Plus there is the cost of implementation. Some estimates put this near $60,000 per physician in a practice.
In this day of declining reimbursement it's hard for many medical practices to take the plunge and invest in this new technology.
Plus there is the whole slew of resistance remarks that range from "it'll slow down my productivity," "I'm too old to learn," "there isn't one for my specialty," and on and on.
Personally (albeit I'm a self professed techno-nerd) I haven't seen any of these problems.
We use a nice cloud based system from AthenaHealth which allows us to limit our on site technical requirements and back up, is constantly up to date, and can be accessed anywhere. Patients can even log in to check their test results, pay their bill, or ask me a question.
The electronic prescribing is phenomenal. I haven't written more than a handful of paper prescriptions in a year or so.
But even with all this technology, I'm not sure that we practice medicine any better today than Dr. Keller did fifty years ago. We just document a whole lot more information.
But is it useful?
We're pretty good at not generating a ream of electronic information every time a patient comes in. Some EMR systems accomplish this task (conventional wisdom is that it might help with coding and therefore reimbursement).
But, we chart way more than Dr. Keller ever did. I hope it's still pertinent to our patients complaint.
What's amazing to me is that as we have advanced in our technology we have become more verbose in our ability to describe it.
You could say that we are "health care bloggers" in the patients' medical record.
Whereas Dr. Keller was more like Twitter. He kept his comments to probably less than 140 characters -- and he did just fine.
So Dr. Keller may have been ahead of his time. Maybe we should "follow" him.
Dr. John Keller is a community icon.
Born south of this small town, he practiced medicine there for over 50 years. Now he's retired, and the community is at a loss.
Though certainly not the cause, his retirement coincided with the roll out of a new electronic medical record, or EMR (sometimes AKA EHR).
This reminded me of a story from Dr. Keller that he related to me over a decade ago. He told me that when he first went into practice records were kept on 3"x 5" note cards.
As someone who has served in various administrative capacities over the years, I've always remembered Dr. Keller's initial non-electronic medical record. And I suspected that his care was super, despite the limitations of space on that card.
Today, EMRs are becoming more and more common. There is still significant resistance from some physicians because of the lack of a unified national standard of connectivity.
That is, one system still can't talk to another.
Plus there is the cost of implementation. Some estimates put this near $60,000 per physician in a practice.
In this day of declining reimbursement it's hard for many medical practices to take the plunge and invest in this new technology.
Plus there is the whole slew of resistance remarks that range from "it'll slow down my productivity," "I'm too old to learn," "there isn't one for my specialty," and on and on.
Personally (albeit I'm a self professed techno-nerd) I haven't seen any of these problems.
We use a nice cloud based system from AthenaHealth which allows us to limit our on site technical requirements and back up, is constantly up to date, and can be accessed anywhere. Patients can even log in to check their test results, pay their bill, or ask me a question.
The electronic prescribing is phenomenal. I haven't written more than a handful of paper prescriptions in a year or so.
But even with all this technology, I'm not sure that we practice medicine any better today than Dr. Keller did fifty years ago. We just document a whole lot more information.
But is it useful?
We're pretty good at not generating a ream of electronic information every time a patient comes in. Some EMR systems accomplish this task (conventional wisdom is that it might help with coding and therefore reimbursement).
But, we chart way more than Dr. Keller ever did. I hope it's still pertinent to our patients complaint.
What's amazing to me is that as we have advanced in our technology we have become more verbose in our ability to describe it.
You could say that we are "health care bloggers" in the patients' medical record.
Whereas Dr. Keller was more like Twitter. He kept his comments to probably less than 140 characters -- and he did just fine.
So Dr. Keller may have been ahead of his time. Maybe we should "follow" him.
Labels:
athenahealth,
blog,
cloud,
cloud computing,
electronic prescribing,
emr,
Fairfield,
health record,
john keller,
twitter
Tuesday, March 15, 2011
How a dying child tells his parents he's ready to die
My good friend and Fort Worth pediatrician Gary Floyd relates this telling story about working with a family through the death of their child from cystic fibrosis. Gary's story is compelling, really...downright tear jerking. This video is part of a series from the Texas Medical Association that began as project from their creative social media guru Steve Levine. Check out other videos from that series here.
Labels:
children,
cystic fibrosis,
death,
dying,
Fort Worth,
Gary Floyd,
letting go,
parents,
Texas Medical Association,
TMA
Injections: Does hurting children now, hurt their health care decisions later
For a long time I ran a large multi-specialty group medical practice in a relatively small town. One of our most active divisions was pediatrics.
Ruby was a nurse in the department for almost 30 years and she had seen probably half the community's children grow into fine healthy adults.
But one day I ran into Ruby at the local Walmart about the time that a group of small children rounded the corner. I also stopped to visit with the nice lady.
The children, though, turned, ran, and cried to their mother.
Ruby commented to me that this was a common but unfortunate occurrence for her.
She was the "shot lady."
Hypodermic injections are one of the earliest memories that children have about health care. In fact, if you ask a young child about the necessity to go to the doctor, the child (and many adults as well) will respond, "I don't need a shot."
Physicians, nurses, and mothers over the years have devised a whole host of tricks to encourage children to get the needle.
Bribery is a favorite of mine: "we'll go get ice cream," "we'll stop on the way home and ...", or the most recent experience for an 18 year old in my office -- "we'll stop at Nordstrom's and get your makeup done."
Threats seem to work for some children. It usually is a threat about "worse pain" than the actual injection. If children are old enough to reason even a little, then the fear of being beat with a belt is usually enough to motivate one for the measles shot.
But it doesn't always work that way. A couple of years ago a father threatened to whip a 14 year old in my office if she didn't submit to an injection.
(Just for the record, I'm opposed to corporal punishment.)
Some nurses and parents are particularly good at trickery. Either there is a ruse on coming to the doctor in the first place ("mommy is here to see the doctor" only to find out that "little Johnny is getting a flu shot"), or my absolute favorite: "this won't hurt a bit."
Well, it never hurts me.
Sometimes health care workers can't bring themselves to completely lie about the pain, so they'll compare it to something more familiar and hopefully more palatable.
Like a bee sting.
That one always makes me calm down.
"Yes, it will feel like a small furry creature is inserting a stinger into your skin and blasting poison away."
You're calm now, aren't you?
Brute force is sometimes an option, particularly if it's a young child.
There is a device for young children called a "papoose board" which is a politically correct way of saying "straight jacket."
Children are strapped in the device which has various holes and openings that allow physician or nurse access to desirable locations -- like those for an injection.
This isn't effective when children get above three or four. They are just too strong and our staff and parents are too weak.
Attempts are sometimes made with this modality and usually everyone ends up in positions that would rival team wrestling at the Dallas Sportatorium.
Negotiation is sometimes employed, with very mixed results (usually followed by one of the items listed above.)
You see with injections there's really no "compromise." So negotiation is doomed from the beginning.
You can't end up only "injecting the needle a little bit" or using a "very small needle" or avoiding the injection altogether -- which is the only solution that most children will agree with.
But in the end, most children are traumatized in some way by the experience. I'm not saying that they shouldn't be receiving injections, rather I'm just saying most children leave with short-lived tears and long-term fear of physicians and going to the doctor.
So the question is does this affect their desire to go the physician later in life for regular, and possibly preventative health care?
Particularly if the primal image of your first health care experience is clouded with pain.
Do you put off the flu shot? The breast exam? The prostate exam? Just your annual physical because of some underlying deep seated sub-cortical negative early experience.
I think many patients do.
Going to the doctor is often a painful experience. Some things just hurt.
But I do believe that anything that physicians and nurses can do to mitigate the pain has a positive effect on that person's future health care decisions.
I like to compare it to swimming. As a scuba diver and water lover I think it's essential for children to learn to swim.
Aside from the obvious reason that it helps to avoid drowning, it also opens up a wonderful world of water sport experiences that otherwise might be avoided.
Children who are taught to not to fear the water, but learn how to interact with it in a positive manner -- playing, floating, blowing bubbles -- usually learn to swim quickly.
Their fear is gone and what comes with it is a learning that water can be safe.
Health care is no different for children.
If they are taught that physicians and nurses shouldn't be feared, then the overall calm atmosphere raises the pain threshold for the children.
Anxiety is the biggest cause for most pain. Children, and even adults, have "fear of pain."
Teaching patients and especially children that pain does occur with procedures but you are there to help them with it can go a long way to prevent an adverse outcome.
Of course, some children are just too small to be able to understand, or they carry with them feelings and fears from other providers into the office. In that case it's, of course, more difficult.
In our office it is important to me that children have the least pain possible and the most positive experience. If we can find a less painful solution, we try to do that. If it's impossible, then we explain the procedure, and the pain, and we work with that patient to make it as comfortable as possible.
I would love to hear from parents and providers on their ideas and solutions to creating positive interactions with children and painful procedures. I'm sure I have a lot to learn.
And I don't want children to run away crying when they see me at Walmart!
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
Ruby was a nurse in the department for almost 30 years and she had seen probably half the community's children grow into fine healthy adults.
But one day I ran into Ruby at the local Walmart about the time that a group of small children rounded the corner. I also stopped to visit with the nice lady.
The children, though, turned, ran, and cried to their mother.
Ruby commented to me that this was a common but unfortunate occurrence for her.
She was the "shot lady."
Hypodermic injections are one of the earliest memories that children have about health care. In fact, if you ask a young child about the necessity to go to the doctor, the child (and many adults as well) will respond, "I don't need a shot."
Physicians, nurses, and mothers over the years have devised a whole host of tricks to encourage children to get the needle.
Bribery is a favorite of mine: "we'll go get ice cream," "we'll stop on the way home and ...", or the most recent experience for an 18 year old in my office -- "we'll stop at Nordstrom's and get your makeup done."
Threats seem to work for some children. It usually is a threat about "worse pain" than the actual injection. If children are old enough to reason even a little, then the fear of being beat with a belt is usually enough to motivate one for the measles shot.
But it doesn't always work that way. A couple of years ago a father threatened to whip a 14 year old in my office if she didn't submit to an injection.
(Just for the record, I'm opposed to corporal punishment.)
Some nurses and parents are particularly good at trickery. Either there is a ruse on coming to the doctor in the first place ("mommy is here to see the doctor" only to find out that "little Johnny is getting a flu shot"), or my absolute favorite: "this won't hurt a bit."
Well, it never hurts me.
Sometimes health care workers can't bring themselves to completely lie about the pain, so they'll compare it to something more familiar and hopefully more palatable.
Like a bee sting.
That one always makes me calm down.
"Yes, it will feel like a small furry creature is inserting a stinger into your skin and blasting poison away."
You're calm now, aren't you?
Brute force is sometimes an option, particularly if it's a young child.
There is a device for young children called a "papoose board" which is a politically correct way of saying "straight jacket."
Children are strapped in the device which has various holes and openings that allow physician or nurse access to desirable locations -- like those for an injection.
This isn't effective when children get above three or four. They are just too strong and our staff and parents are too weak.
Attempts are sometimes made with this modality and usually everyone ends up in positions that would rival team wrestling at the Dallas Sportatorium.
Negotiation is sometimes employed, with very mixed results (usually followed by one of the items listed above.)
You see with injections there's really no "compromise." So negotiation is doomed from the beginning.
You can't end up only "injecting the needle a little bit" or using a "very small needle" or avoiding the injection altogether -- which is the only solution that most children will agree with.
But in the end, most children are traumatized in some way by the experience. I'm not saying that they shouldn't be receiving injections, rather I'm just saying most children leave with short-lived tears and long-term fear of physicians and going to the doctor.
So the question is does this affect their desire to go the physician later in life for regular, and possibly preventative health care?
Particularly if the primal image of your first health care experience is clouded with pain.
Do you put off the flu shot? The breast exam? The prostate exam? Just your annual physical because of some underlying deep seated sub-cortical negative early experience.
I think many patients do.
Going to the doctor is often a painful experience. Some things just hurt.
But I do believe that anything that physicians and nurses can do to mitigate the pain has a positive effect on that person's future health care decisions.
I like to compare it to swimming. As a scuba diver and water lover I think it's essential for children to learn to swim.
Aside from the obvious reason that it helps to avoid drowning, it also opens up a wonderful world of water sport experiences that otherwise might be avoided.
Children who are taught to not to fear the water, but learn how to interact with it in a positive manner -- playing, floating, blowing bubbles -- usually learn to swim quickly.
Their fear is gone and what comes with it is a learning that water can be safe.
Health care is no different for children.
If they are taught that physicians and nurses shouldn't be feared, then the overall calm atmosphere raises the pain threshold for the children.
Anxiety is the biggest cause for most pain. Children, and even adults, have "fear of pain."
Teaching patients and especially children that pain does occur with procedures but you are there to help them with it can go a long way to prevent an adverse outcome.
Of course, some children are just too small to be able to understand, or they carry with them feelings and fears from other providers into the office. In that case it's, of course, more difficult.
In our office it is important to me that children have the least pain possible and the most positive experience. If we can find a less painful solution, we try to do that. If it's impossible, then we explain the procedure, and the pain, and we work with that patient to make it as comfortable as possible.
I would love to hear from parents and providers on their ideas and solutions to creating positive interactions with children and painful procedures. I'm sure I have a lot to learn.
And I don't want children to run away crying when they see me at Walmart!
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
Location:Dallas, Texas
Labels:
children,
fear,
fear of needles,
hypodermic,
injections,
nurses,
pain,
pediatrics,
physicians,
shot,
swimming,
vaccinations
Sunday, March 13, 2011
When Cancer is a Family Affair
By Linda Timmerman, Ed.D.
According to a report from the CDC, there are nearly 12 million cancer survivors in the U.S. today.
That's 12 million people seeking "new normal" in their lives. Twelve million journeys. Twelve million stories.
Every cancer survivor is an individual, and no two journeys are alike.
My family of cancer survivors is a microcosm of those 12 million courageous souls.
My 86-year-old Dad approached his diagnosis of bladder cancer some 20 years ago the way he has always approached life: philosophically and through scripture. Ask about his cancer and he'll respond: "It happens. My God is in control, and I don't worry about it."
He does, however, think deeply about his cancer.
Shortly after he had completed his three-year maintenance protocol of BCG (Bacillus Calmette-Guerin, an inactivated form of the bovine tuberculosis virus that is instilled into the bladder to elicit an immune response), he called me and asked, "now that my treatment is over -- do I tell people I HAD cancer, or do I say I HAVE cancer?"
He's deeply interested in knowing how he got bladder cancer in the first place: he was a smoker for a number of years, but hadn't smoked in over 25 years when diagnosed. He was a dairy farmer exposed to pesticides and chemicals virtually every day.
Truthfully, it was Dad who found an article about BCG in Reader's Digest in 1991, took it to his urologist, and said, "they say this is a fairly new and promising treatment for bladder cancer -- can we try it?" It worked for him -- he's been in remission almost 20 years.
Today, BCG is still the gold standard for immunotherapy for bladder cancer.
Dad spends hours pondering the fact that I, his only daughter (who is still 16 years old in his mind), has bladder cancer and that having a first degree relative with bladder cancer is a risk factor.
"How did I pass that on to you?" he'll ask. Is there some test your children can take to see if they carry the gene?
My Mom, on the other hand, approached her journey with fear and trepidation. Mom is the official family worrier. She called me one day to say that she was so worried, "things are going so well, I just know something bad's about to happen."
Mom thought her lung cancer diagnosis meant certain death.
She grew up in that era. She and I were both there when her mother, my grandmother, died -- drowning in her own fluids from breast cancer that had metastasized to the lungs.
Mom didn't know many survivors in her life.
Mom never came to see me when I was undergoing treatment for breast cancer. She just couldn't. And I completely understood.
To this day, Mom can't believe that her cancer is gone. "All they did was remove the upper left lobe of my lung," she'll say. "The doctors say I didn't need chemo. It'll probably come back."
She has to worry. I completely understand.
My husband approaches his cancer stoically. He has had three melanomas, but rarely talks about it and doesn't want anyone to "make a big deal" of it. He has a skin condition that requires him to use ultra-violet light therapy weekly. It has to worry him that he exposes his skin to UVB light, but he does it without complaint.
He is vigilant. He visits his dermatologist regularly and uses sun screen religiously.
He and I faced our biggest fear two years ago when his daughter, my step-daughter, was diagnosed with a liposarcoma in her leg. This was different for our family: she was too young, and the mother of young children.
The biopsy was clear, but pathology on the very large tumor showed that approximately one-third of the mass was cancerous. They couldn't remove all of the tumor without removing her leg.
She is teaching us how to use humor to cope. She respects the disease, and she knows that she must be followed closely for the rest of her life. She will do what it takes to thrive and survive.
I cope by being involved.
I participate in cancer "causes," -- Relay for Life, the Koman Breast Cancer 3-Day walk, I attend a support group for bladder cancer survivors, I speak to groups, I counsel fellow survivors, I raise money for cancer research, and I blog.
I use this involvement to find my "new normal." I use it to challenge the disease that has invaded my life and the life of people I hold dear: my husband, child, mom, and dad. My prayer is that my children and grandchildren will never have to battle this disease in any form.
12 Million Survivors. 12 Million journeys. 12 Million ways to cope. It's a good thing. It gives me hope.
Linda Timmerman, Ed. D. is a two-time cancer survivor and life long educator. She blogs regularly about cancer survival and real information from real people with the disease.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
According to a report from the CDC, there are nearly 12 million cancer survivors in the U.S. today.
That's 12 million people seeking "new normal" in their lives. Twelve million journeys. Twelve million stories.
Every cancer survivor is an individual, and no two journeys are alike.
My family of cancer survivors is a microcosm of those 12 million courageous souls.
My 86-year-old Dad approached his diagnosis of bladder cancer some 20 years ago the way he has always approached life: philosophically and through scripture. Ask about his cancer and he'll respond: "It happens. My God is in control, and I don't worry about it."
He does, however, think deeply about his cancer.
Shortly after he had completed his three-year maintenance protocol of BCG (Bacillus Calmette-Guerin, an inactivated form of the bovine tuberculosis virus that is instilled into the bladder to elicit an immune response), he called me and asked, "now that my treatment is over -- do I tell people I HAD cancer, or do I say I HAVE cancer?"
He's deeply interested in knowing how he got bladder cancer in the first place: he was a smoker for a number of years, but hadn't smoked in over 25 years when diagnosed. He was a dairy farmer exposed to pesticides and chemicals virtually every day.
Truthfully, it was Dad who found an article about BCG in Reader's Digest in 1991, took it to his urologist, and said, "they say this is a fairly new and promising treatment for bladder cancer -- can we try it?" It worked for him -- he's been in remission almost 20 years.
Today, BCG is still the gold standard for immunotherapy for bladder cancer.
Dad spends hours pondering the fact that I, his only daughter (who is still 16 years old in his mind), has bladder cancer and that having a first degree relative with bladder cancer is a risk factor.
"How did I pass that on to you?" he'll ask. Is there some test your children can take to see if they carry the gene?
My Mom, on the other hand, approached her journey with fear and trepidation. Mom is the official family worrier. She called me one day to say that she was so worried, "things are going so well, I just know something bad's about to happen."
Mom thought her lung cancer diagnosis meant certain death.
She grew up in that era. She and I were both there when her mother, my grandmother, died -- drowning in her own fluids from breast cancer that had metastasized to the lungs.
Mom didn't know many survivors in her life.
Mom never came to see me when I was undergoing treatment for breast cancer. She just couldn't. And I completely understood.
To this day, Mom can't believe that her cancer is gone. "All they did was remove the upper left lobe of my lung," she'll say. "The doctors say I didn't need chemo. It'll probably come back."
She has to worry. I completely understand.
My husband approaches his cancer stoically. He has had three melanomas, but rarely talks about it and doesn't want anyone to "make a big deal" of it. He has a skin condition that requires him to use ultra-violet light therapy weekly. It has to worry him that he exposes his skin to UVB light, but he does it without complaint.
He is vigilant. He visits his dermatologist regularly and uses sun screen religiously.
He and I faced our biggest fear two years ago when his daughter, my step-daughter, was diagnosed with a liposarcoma in her leg. This was different for our family: she was too young, and the mother of young children.
The biopsy was clear, but pathology on the very large tumor showed that approximately one-third of the mass was cancerous. They couldn't remove all of the tumor without removing her leg.
She is teaching us how to use humor to cope. She respects the disease, and she knows that she must be followed closely for the rest of her life. She will do what it takes to thrive and survive.
I cope by being involved.
I participate in cancer "causes," -- Relay for Life, the Koman Breast Cancer 3-Day walk, I attend a support group for bladder cancer survivors, I speak to groups, I counsel fellow survivors, I raise money for cancer research, and I blog.
I use this involvement to find my "new normal." I use it to challenge the disease that has invaded my life and the life of people I hold dear: my husband, child, mom, and dad. My prayer is that my children and grandchildren will never have to battle this disease in any form.
12 Million Survivors. 12 Million journeys. 12 Million ways to cope. It's a good thing. It gives me hope.
Linda Timmerman, Ed. D. is a two-time cancer survivor and life long educator. She blogs regularly about cancer survival and real information from real people with the disease.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
Labels:
BCG,
bladder cancer,
breast cancer,
cancer,
CDC,
coping,
liposarcoma,
melanoma,
new normal,
Reader's Digest,
survival,
UVB
Saturday, March 12, 2011
"docdano. com Live" Protesting in Wisconsin: Is Obamacare at the root of the debate?
I spoke last night to a group of young physicians at a venue across the street from the Wisconsin State Capitol at the height of the protest against the state government.
Amid the drum beats and screams of union organizers chanting how workers' rights would be eternally devastated because of the loss of collective bargaining, I lectured to a group of resident physicians on the benefits that await patients with the explosion in health care technology.
The root of the problem centers around a state, like almost all in the country, that is saddled with loss of tax revenues due to the downturn in the economy. This has resulted in massive budget deficits and hard choices.
Many states including Wisconsin have ushered in a flurry of Republicans who ran on campaigns of no new taxes, the need to cut waste and spending, and more state's rights.
So that's what the Republican Governor did from day one in office.
He first attempted to limit spending on education to trim the budget, but because of collective bargaining the negotiation of this type of decrease in the state spending was not palatable to the unions.
It didn't matter, really, because the Republicans had the votes to pass it anyway.
But instead of voting on this budgetary issue, the Democrats chose to flee to the land of Obama in Illinois to prevent the state legislature from reaching the critical number of votes to make a quorum.
For three weeks this stalled the debate and decision on the issue, until the Republicans decided to pull out the budget issues (which require the quorum) and vote instead on non-budgetary items - like collective bargaining.
So this lead to more protests.
I literally visited with hundreds of people in Wisconsin over the past week and different opinions abound from every direction.
Clearly if you are a member of the "haves" then you have no desire to give up a benefit.
That's normal.
One person told me that his daughter is a unionized teacher and she pays a whopping $23 a month for health care insurance with no deductible. Even if you factor in that there might be some requirements for her to see certain physicians in network or limitations on formulary and specialist access, this is still a bargain.
He went on tell me that the Governor's proposal would have raised this to $123 per month. I don't know if these numbers are accurate, but the change in benefit structure certainly spurred part of the protest that had national attention.
If you've read this blog before, you know that I'm not a fan of the Obamacare bill. And I think you are seeing in Wisconsin one end of the spectrum of the problems with the bill.
Let me show you why.
To pay for the extra benefits offered under the bill (like no pre-existing illness exclusion, limitations on the right of rescission of insurance if you're too sick to be in the plan, or extended coverage for children), then there will have to be either more money (read tax dollars or higher premiums) or a decline in benefits for those that are members of the "haves."
It's really that simple.
State governments who have been charged with implementing many of the provisions of the federal health care bill don't have the ability to print money or sell treasury bonds. Their only source of revenue is tax dollars.
A significant part of Obama's plan was to provide health insurance for "all Americans." And, unfortunately, a large number of the uninsured were to be covered with the under funded, limited access Medicaid system -- much of which is paid for by the states.
Finding revenue for Medicaid means that other state funded services - like education, or health benefits for teachers - have to be cut and shifted.
That is the only possible way to fund insurance for the "have nots."
I've been derided for one of my statements in the past, but I stand by it: the Obamacare health regulation was the largest transfer of wealth in American history.
So the union supported President now finds himself supporting the union backed protesters who are fighting against changes in state government that would be used to pay for the health care bill that he (and the unions) supported.
Wisconsin is only a microcosm of what is happening in every state that is now grappling with implementing the federal health legislation in a time of budget crisis.
It is an expensive bill, and now we are starting to pay the price.
I'm a big fan of expanding health care access and coverage for the "have nots." A country like the United States should be ashamed for having citizens that don't have access to quality health care. I'm just not a supporter of the big, expensive, inefficient and over-reaching federal health care bill that was passed last year.
Let's face it: the bill cost the taxpayers almost $1 trillion.
The payment for the bill is due now.
And lest you think that non-government workers will get a free ride and this is just an issue for state employees - it will filter down to every American.
As health plans shift to include the new benefits, pay the taxes and fees that are now required by the IRS, and see declining membership due to employees shifting to government subsidized insurance products there will no doubt either be an increase in your health care premiums or a reduction in your benefits.
The problem is that for many insured Americans there is no union to fight for your corporate benefits.
It will be left up to you.
One Wisconsin young man told me that maybe the Republicans should have left Congress when the health care bill was passed.
I reminded him that democracy doesn't work this way. We elect people to represent us and sometimes we win, and sometimes we lose.
I think the Obamacare bill is failure, but I believe strongly that we can keep what's good and fix what's broken. We just have to continue the debate, make compromises, and yes, probably make some sacrifices.
So it probably won't be the last protest I'll attend. Maybe next time I'll get to carry a sign...I'm not much of a drum beater.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
Amid the drum beats and screams of union organizers chanting how workers' rights would be eternally devastated because of the loss of collective bargaining, I lectured to a group of resident physicians on the benefits that await patients with the explosion in health care technology.
The root of the problem centers around a state, like almost all in the country, that is saddled with loss of tax revenues due to the downturn in the economy. This has resulted in massive budget deficits and hard choices.
Many states including Wisconsin have ushered in a flurry of Republicans who ran on campaigns of no new taxes, the need to cut waste and spending, and more state's rights.
So that's what the Republican Governor did from day one in office.
He first attempted to limit spending on education to trim the budget, but because of collective bargaining the negotiation of this type of decrease in the state spending was not palatable to the unions.
It didn't matter, really, because the Republicans had the votes to pass it anyway.
But instead of voting on this budgetary issue, the Democrats chose to flee to the land of Obama in Illinois to prevent the state legislature from reaching the critical number of votes to make a quorum.
For three weeks this stalled the debate and decision on the issue, until the Republicans decided to pull out the budget issues (which require the quorum) and vote instead on non-budgetary items - like collective bargaining.
So this lead to more protests.
I literally visited with hundreds of people in Wisconsin over the past week and different opinions abound from every direction.
Clearly if you are a member of the "haves" then you have no desire to give up a benefit.
That's normal.
One person told me that his daughter is a unionized teacher and she pays a whopping $23 a month for health care insurance with no deductible. Even if you factor in that there might be some requirements for her to see certain physicians in network or limitations on formulary and specialist access, this is still a bargain.
He went on tell me that the Governor's proposal would have raised this to $123 per month. I don't know if these numbers are accurate, but the change in benefit structure certainly spurred part of the protest that had national attention.
If you've read this blog before, you know that I'm not a fan of the Obamacare bill. And I think you are seeing in Wisconsin one end of the spectrum of the problems with the bill.
Let me show you why.
To pay for the extra benefits offered under the bill (like no pre-existing illness exclusion, limitations on the right of rescission of insurance if you're too sick to be in the plan, or extended coverage for children), then there will have to be either more money (read tax dollars or higher premiums) or a decline in benefits for those that are members of the "haves."
It's really that simple.
State governments who have been charged with implementing many of the provisions of the federal health care bill don't have the ability to print money or sell treasury bonds. Their only source of revenue is tax dollars.
A significant part of Obama's plan was to provide health insurance for "all Americans." And, unfortunately, a large number of the uninsured were to be covered with the under funded, limited access Medicaid system -- much of which is paid for by the states.
Finding revenue for Medicaid means that other state funded services - like education, or health benefits for teachers - have to be cut and shifted.
That is the only possible way to fund insurance for the "have nots."
I've been derided for one of my statements in the past, but I stand by it: the Obamacare health regulation was the largest transfer of wealth in American history.
So the union supported President now finds himself supporting the union backed protesters who are fighting against changes in state government that would be used to pay for the health care bill that he (and the unions) supported.
Wisconsin is only a microcosm of what is happening in every state that is now grappling with implementing the federal health legislation in a time of budget crisis.
It is an expensive bill, and now we are starting to pay the price.
I'm a big fan of expanding health care access and coverage for the "have nots." A country like the United States should be ashamed for having citizens that don't have access to quality health care. I'm just not a supporter of the big, expensive, inefficient and over-reaching federal health care bill that was passed last year.
Let's face it: the bill cost the taxpayers almost $1 trillion.
The payment for the bill is due now.
And lest you think that non-government workers will get a free ride and this is just an issue for state employees - it will filter down to every American.
As health plans shift to include the new benefits, pay the taxes and fees that are now required by the IRS, and see declining membership due to employees shifting to government subsidized insurance products there will no doubt either be an increase in your health care premiums or a reduction in your benefits.
The problem is that for many insured Americans there is no union to fight for your corporate benefits.
It will be left up to you.
One Wisconsin young man told me that maybe the Republicans should have left Congress when the health care bill was passed.
I reminded him that democracy doesn't work this way. We elect people to represent us and sometimes we win, and sometimes we lose.
I think the Obamacare bill is failure, but I believe strongly that we can keep what's good and fix what's broken. We just have to continue the debate, make compromises, and yes, probably make some sacrifices.
So it probably won't be the last protest I'll attend. Maybe next time I'll get to carry a sign...I'm not much of a drum beater.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
Location:State Capitol, Madison, Wisconsin
Wednesday, March 9, 2011
Vaccinations: Is death the only motivator that works to promote immunization?
A recent conversation with my nurse and regular debating partner highlighted the passion that people have about vaccinations.
We were finishing up clinic and the topic of HPV came up.
(Now, don't be surprised. This issue is something that we deal with almost every hour of every day.)
There is a vaccination now for certain subtypes of HPV, which not only cause genital warts but also can lead to cancer in women and men.
Cervical cancer particularly is an epidemic disease among young women. And the "abnormal Pap smear" has become as frequent as many common diseases.
Women infected with the virus can develop dysplasia (atypical, precancerous cells) of the cervix which if not recognized and treated can lead to both a superficial and invasive malignancy.
The dysplasia needs to be treated with painful procedures like cryosurgery, or a cone biopsy where the affected tissue is surgically removed, to the possibility of a hysterectomy.
Aside from the fact that the vaccination is really directed to young women, it is clear that young men are also parties to the transmission of the virus. And, there is a cancer risk in men as HPV can lead to not just cometic genital warts, but also to penile cancer.
My nurse was adamant about her son not having the vaccination.
She is certainly entitled to her opinion and it's a common thought among many young parents these days.
Plus, lets face it, men serve as reservoirs of the disease for women.
So, why does she have such a strong opinion?
I mentioned this discussion to my father who in less than a month will be 91. He couldn't grasp why someone would ever turn down a vaccination.
His opinion is grounded in growing up where epidemic infections were a regular cause of death for young adults, including his family and friends.
"I can remember when my cousin died of polio. We burned all of her bed clothes and put phenol around the house," he told me.
"Then we buried her."
So what happened when the vaccine came about I asked?
"We lined up downtown at the community center. Everyone in town."
"No one felt like the government was forcing them to get vaccinated? Did anyone refuse?"
"I can't remember anyone who didn't want it. I mean, almost everyone had lost a member of their family, or a child. You didn't have to see many people in a wheel chair or an iron lung to put the fear of God in you about polio."
So that's the culture that I grew up in. My parents used every opportunity to have me punctured by a hypodermic to keep me from dying of polio, and lock jaw (tetanus), two kinds of measles, and whooping cough.
They must have also wanted to continue the blood line too because mumps was also put "at bay" and my testicles protected with a series of injections.
So maybe death is the big motivator for vaccination.
If you look at college campuses now almost all of them have been affected by meningitis. Students have died of the disease so frequently in the past few years and it is so contagious that most schools require vaccination before you can gain admittance.
I remember the first patient I ever admitted to the ICU as an intern almost 18 years ago now.
She was a 24-year old waitress at one of the Dallas cowboy bars. You know the drill: fever, chills, altered mental status, and finally collapse in the ER.
She got the finest treatment a major tertiary center could offer. But she still descended to the brink of death.
There was a ventilator, multiple consultants, loads of IV antibiotics, and plenty of hand holding from a pimple faced intern who saw someone younger than him dying.
There was no vaccination for meningitis in those days. We gowned and gloved when we took care of her. And we all took prophylactic antibiotics lest we succumb to the same fate.
And we waited, and yes, I prayed for her.
It's not that I just didn't want to strike out at my first bat with a patient in the ICU.
I met her family, her boyfriend, and friends. I got to know her.
And thankfully I witnessed her get better. It took the better part of a month, but we were able to give her the hospital equivalent of the perp-walk in a wheel chair to the front door with balloons, plants, and the to go bag containing the pink ice pitcher give-away from the hospital room.
But for the other diseases nobody dies.
Does this decrease motivation for vaccination?
It probably does. I can assure you my children will be vaccinated against meningitis.
Chicken pox maybe is an exception. Public health officials were successful in convincing parents in our state to require this for elementary school attendance.
I would like to think that it was because chicken pox can lead to devastating scars in children and to permanent pain in adults when it reappears as shingles.
More likely, the primary concern was the missed school days for the kids and missed work for the parents.
But today most parents line their kids up for chicken pox and also hepatitis B vaccinations without much consternation.
Oh, but not for the HPV vaccine.
It may be the social stigma of the disease, or the fact that their children either shouldn't be or won't be doing anything to put them at risk for the disease.
I even still the absurd argument I hear about the birth control pill: that it might promote promiscuity.
My opinion is no doubt clouded by practicing every day at a major urban metropolitan hospital. What I see is real world. But it may not be your world.
I guess I grew up with the values from my father. If modern medicine can protect children or adults from ailments or infirmities then I am easy to buy in.
Whether its small pox or HPV, I support vaccination and elimination of these diseases from the society I call home.
I no longer have to see someone die to become a cheerleader.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
We were finishing up clinic and the topic of HPV came up.
(Now, don't be surprised. This issue is something that we deal with almost every hour of every day.)
There is a vaccination now for certain subtypes of HPV, which not only cause genital warts but also can lead to cancer in women and men.
Cervical cancer particularly is an epidemic disease among young women. And the "abnormal Pap smear" has become as frequent as many common diseases.
Women infected with the virus can develop dysplasia (atypical, precancerous cells) of the cervix which if not recognized and treated can lead to both a superficial and invasive malignancy.
The dysplasia needs to be treated with painful procedures like cryosurgery, or a cone biopsy where the affected tissue is surgically removed, to the possibility of a hysterectomy.
Aside from the fact that the vaccination is really directed to young women, it is clear that young men are also parties to the transmission of the virus. And, there is a cancer risk in men as HPV can lead to not just cometic genital warts, but also to penile cancer.
My nurse was adamant about her son not having the vaccination.
She is certainly entitled to her opinion and it's a common thought among many young parents these days.
Plus, lets face it, men serve as reservoirs of the disease for women.
So, why does she have such a strong opinion?
I mentioned this discussion to my father who in less than a month will be 91. He couldn't grasp why someone would ever turn down a vaccination.
His opinion is grounded in growing up where epidemic infections were a regular cause of death for young adults, including his family and friends.
"I can remember when my cousin died of polio. We burned all of her bed clothes and put phenol around the house," he told me.
"Then we buried her."
So what happened when the vaccine came about I asked?
"We lined up downtown at the community center. Everyone in town."
"No one felt like the government was forcing them to get vaccinated? Did anyone refuse?"
"I can't remember anyone who didn't want it. I mean, almost everyone had lost a member of their family, or a child. You didn't have to see many people in a wheel chair or an iron lung to put the fear of God in you about polio."
So that's the culture that I grew up in. My parents used every opportunity to have me punctured by a hypodermic to keep me from dying of polio, and lock jaw (tetanus), two kinds of measles, and whooping cough.
They must have also wanted to continue the blood line too because mumps was also put "at bay" and my testicles protected with a series of injections.
So maybe death is the big motivator for vaccination.
If you look at college campuses now almost all of them have been affected by meningitis. Students have died of the disease so frequently in the past few years and it is so contagious that most schools require vaccination before you can gain admittance.
I remember the first patient I ever admitted to the ICU as an intern almost 18 years ago now.
She was a 24-year old waitress at one of the Dallas cowboy bars. You know the drill: fever, chills, altered mental status, and finally collapse in the ER.
She got the finest treatment a major tertiary center could offer. But she still descended to the brink of death.
There was a ventilator, multiple consultants, loads of IV antibiotics, and plenty of hand holding from a pimple faced intern who saw someone younger than him dying.
There was no vaccination for meningitis in those days. We gowned and gloved when we took care of her. And we all took prophylactic antibiotics lest we succumb to the same fate.
And we waited, and yes, I prayed for her.
It's not that I just didn't want to strike out at my first bat with a patient in the ICU.
I met her family, her boyfriend, and friends. I got to know her.
And thankfully I witnessed her get better. It took the better part of a month, but we were able to give her the hospital equivalent of the perp-walk in a wheel chair to the front door with balloons, plants, and the to go bag containing the pink ice pitcher give-away from the hospital room.
But for the other diseases nobody dies.
Does this decrease motivation for vaccination?
It probably does. I can assure you my children will be vaccinated against meningitis.
Chicken pox maybe is an exception. Public health officials were successful in convincing parents in our state to require this for elementary school attendance.
I would like to think that it was because chicken pox can lead to devastating scars in children and to permanent pain in adults when it reappears as shingles.
More likely, the primary concern was the missed school days for the kids and missed work for the parents.
But today most parents line their kids up for chicken pox and also hepatitis B vaccinations without much consternation.
Oh, but not for the HPV vaccine.
It may be the social stigma of the disease, or the fact that their children either shouldn't be or won't be doing anything to put them at risk for the disease.
I even still the absurd argument I hear about the birth control pill: that it might promote promiscuity.
My opinion is no doubt clouded by practicing every day at a major urban metropolitan hospital. What I see is real world. But it may not be your world.
I guess I grew up with the values from my father. If modern medicine can protect children or adults from ailments or infirmities then I am easy to buy in.
Whether its small pox or HPV, I support vaccination and elimination of these diseases from the society I call home.
I no longer have to see someone die to become a cheerleader.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
Location:Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Labels:
biopsy,
cervical cancer,
children,
Gardesil,
genital warts,
HPV,
immunizations,
meningitis,
polio,
small pox,
vaccinations
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)